Reading Time: 5 minutes

The Unspoken Ranking of University Degrees

Share this article:

Malaysian university students from different backgrounds collaborate in a learning environment, reflecting the diversity of academic disciplines and opportunities in higher education. This piece explores the unspoken hierarchy surrounding academic disciplines, how it shapes students’ choices and why we should look beyond a degree’s earning potential to recognise its value. Photo: Illustrative image.

Something is interesting about telling people what you study at university. Some degrees seem to speak for themselves, while others invite a follow-up question.

Whenever someone tells me they study medicine, the reaction is usually predictable: a look of admiration, perhaps a comment about how difficult the course must be, followed by congratulations. But when I tell people I study Biomedical Science, or simply biology, the conversation tends to take a different turn.

“So, what are you going to do with that degree? Isn’t it difficult to find a good job with a biology degree?”

“Doesn’t a biology degree offer limited opportunities in the working world, especially in Malaysia?”

I have grown familiar with these reactions. While some people are simply curious, others seem to assume that a biology degree offers limited career opportunities, particularly for those who do not intend to pursue medicine.

Sponsored Advertisement ⓘ
ads1

But this experience is hardly exclusive to science students. Those pursuing humanities, arts or other less conventional disciplines often face similar questions. What does one do with a philosophy degree? Can an English literature graduate find a job other than teaching? Is studying the arts a financially sensible decision?

Different disciplines, different questions, but perhaps the same underlying assumption: that some degrees are inherently more valuable, respectable and worthwhile than others.

The Hierarchy of Academic Prestige

We have become accustomed to associating certain university degrees with intelligence, academic difficulty and professional success. Medicine, law, engineering, economics and finance are among the obvious examples. They are recognised, respected and often regarded as particularly demanding fields of study.

There is nothing wrong with acknowledging the challenges of these professions. Medical training, for example, requires years of rigorous education, clinical responsibility and commitment.

However, somewhere along the way, we seem to have developed an unspoken hierarchy of academic disciplines, where the perceived value of a degree is often determined by how familiar its career pathway is to the public. You study medicine and become a doctor. You study engineering and become an engineer. The pathway is clear, and the profession is recognisable. Other disciplines, on the other hand, are harder to explain.

What does one do with a biology degree? What about sociology, linguistics or geography? Their career paths may not be immediately obvious, but that does not make them any less valuable. Unfortunately, what is less familiar is sometimes mistaken for what is less worthwhile.

A degree does not necessarily become less rigorous simply because its demands are less recognisable to the public. Every discipline has its own methods, complexities and intellectual challenges.

Of course, different degrees offer different employment opportunities, and some career pathways are more structured than others. My concern is not that all degrees should be considered equal in terms of career prospects, but that we are often too quick to judge an entire field of study without understanding what it entails.

Perhaps it is easier to respect what we already understand. But that should not come at the expense of dismissing what we do not.

When a Degree Becomes an Investment

This perception is also rooted in how we have come to understand higher education. For many students, choosing a university degree is no longer simply about what interests them or what they would like to learn. It is also an investment expected to produce a reasonably predictable return.

We are encouraged to consider graduate salaries, employment rates, career progression and financial security. These are reasonable considerations, but when employability becomes the primary measure of a degree’s worth, we risk reducing education to a transaction.

Before they have even stepped into a lecture theatre, many students are already thinking about the financial returns of their degrees and the industries they might eventually enter. Choosing what to study begins to feel like a make-or-break decision, as though one wrong choice at 18 could determine the rest of their lives.

Consequently, some may gravitate towards degrees promising greater financial security, even when their interests lie elsewhere. A student who enjoys history might hesitate to pursue it because they cannot picture a stable career afterwards. Someone fascinated by the arts might choose another path because they have repeatedly been told it is not a practical way to make a living.

I do not think there is anything wrong with wanting a degree that leads to a well-paying job. Financial stability matters, and not everyone has the privilege of making educational decisions without considering their circumstances. However, we should be careful about allowing the promise of a future salary to become the only reason for choosing a particular path.

After all, we are preparing not only for the next three or four years of study but potentially for decades of working life. It is worth asking whether the career we are pursuing is something we can genuinely see ourselves doing for the next 30 years.

Passion alone does not pay the bills, and enjoying a subject does not guarantee a fulfilling career. But our interests, strengths and aspirations deserve consideration alongside the practical realities of employment.

More importantly, the stigma surrounding less conventional degrees may discourage future students from considering these fields altogether. When young people repeatedly hear that certain degrees offer limited opportunities, they may never discover whether those subjects are where their talents truly lie.

The Applications of Biological Sciences in Everyday Life

Perhaps I can use my own discipline to illustrate why these assumptions deserve a second look.

Studying biology does not mean that one’s only ambition is to become a doctor. Biology is a broad discipline encompassing molecular mechanisms, genetics, human physiology, neuroscience, biotechnology and entire ecosystems. There is a whole world of scientific knowledge beyond the walls of a medical school.

So, what can one do with a biology degree? Graduates can pursue careers in pharmaceutical development, clinical research, healthcare, public health and scientific communication. Some may continue with postgraduate research, while others may apply their scientific knowledge in different industries.

Biological sciences are also deeply embedded in everyday life. The development of new medicines, our understanding of inherited diseases, advances in genetic technologies and personalised medicine all rely on biological research. It is difficult to imagine the advancement of modern healthcare without these contributions.

Rethinking the Value of Higher Education

I understand why people ask what someone intends to do with their degree. Securing employment and building a sustainable future are important considerations. But I wonder whether we have become so preoccupied with the destination that we have forgotten the value of the journey.

University offers young people the opportunity to immerse themselves in a subject, explore unfamiliar ideas and develop an understanding of the world beyond what they previously knew. Some interests may eventually become careers. Others may simply change the way a person thinks. Neither outcome makes the experience any less worthwhile.

There is a difference between helping someone understand the possibilities their degree offers and making them feel that their choice needs defending.

I still do not have a definitive answer whenever someone asks what I intend to do with my Biomedical Science degree. I have interests, possibilities and a few ideas about where I might eventually find myself. But I am also still learning, and perhaps that is exactly what I am supposed to be doing.

So, the next time someone tells you what they study, perhaps resist the urge to immediately ask what they intend to do with it. Ask what they have learnt, what fascinates them or what made them choose that particular subject.

After all, a degree should not have to sound impressive to be meaningful. Sometimes, the most valuable thing we take away from university is not a predetermined career, but a way of thinking that stays with us long after we have proudly walked across the stage to collect our degree.

Author: Sharifah Shazryn Afiefy Syed Atif is studying Biomedical Science at King’s College London. She is participating in The Petri Dish Fellowship Writing Lab.